|
Smoke and mirrors have a lethal chemistry. The link between tobacco use and
our obsession with thinness is one reason medicine is losing the
war on smoking.
Although 32 million of the estimated 46 million American smokers reportedly
want to quit, only 2% to 3% successfully kick the habit each year.
At the same time, more females are taking up smoking, and are projected
to outnumber male smokers by the year 2000. Why this backslide,
even after lung cancer has topped breast cancer as a killer of women?
The answer in part is that women are dying for a smaller dress size. The 5
pound to 10 pound weight gain that accompanies quitting is seen
by some as too high a price to pay in our fat-phobic culture.
From earliest cigarette advertisements ("Reach for a Lucky instead of
a sweet") to today's slinky magazine ads for Virginia Slims
and Capri Superslims, tobacco companies seem to have long exploited
the link with thinness. While the appeal is targeted primarily to
women, men also fear softening their hard bodies.
"Using cigarettes is like using an anorectic [appetite supressing] drug,"
says Janet Gross, a psychologist at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine.
But psychologist Bob Klesges of the University of Memphis argues cigarettes
are a "crummy weight-control strategy," offering an average
eight-pound weight difference, at a high cost of heart, lung, cancer
and reproductive risk.
Joseph Califano, former secretary of Health, Education and Welfare in the Carter
administration, was a four-pack-a-day smoker who gained 30 pounds
when he quit. Now president of Columbia's Center on Addiction and
Substance Abuse, he wishes he had focused more while in Washington
on the deadly synergy between smoking and weight control. "If
you look at pictures of me after I quit, I was jowly," says
Mr. Califano. "I took of 15 pounds by eating less cheese and
dessert, and by jogging."
Stop-smoking campaigns will fail, he believes, unless they tackle the weight
issue head-on. "We have to make it chic to be a non-smoker,"
he says. "And we have to accept the fact that not everybody
has to look like a social X-ray, to borrow a phrase from Tom Wolfe."
To a smoker, current health messages cancel each other out. Smoking and obesity
are denounced as the No. 1 and No. 2 causes of preventable disease
and death. But the American Lung Association is trying to clear
the air by restoring smoking cessation as priority one.
Edwin Fisher, a psychologist at Washington University in St. Louis says people
quitting cigarettes should be reassured that a modest weight gain
not only isn't their fault, but also is biologically programmed.
"Smoking tends to damage metabolism," he says, by reducing the body's
tendency to store energy as fat. "So when people quit smoking,
their body is normalizing, not blimping. They're just responding
to a sudden change in chemical intake."
Nicotine touches off complex biochemical reactions in the body, including stimulation
of the central nervous system and acceleration of the body's basal
metabolism, causing smokers to burn more calories at rest than non-smokers.
Further, nicotine supresses the appetite, and studies suggest its
withdrawal may spark a specific craving for carbohydrates, says
Phyllis Pirie of the University of Minnesota.
When a former is ready for weight control, here's what Dr. Fisher and the Lung
Association recommend:
-
Don't blame yourself for gaining weight. It's partly biological
and partly behavioral.
-
Recognize that quitting smoking is far more important to your
health than a 10 pound weight gain.
-
Get off the merry-go-round of quitting smoking, gaining weight
and resuming smoking to lose weight. Don't put out much effort
to lose weight until you can restrict food intake without experiencing
the urge to smoke. For most people this will take six months.
-
Exercise. It's a good solution for both quitting smoking and
for weight management. It reduces tension formerly soothed by
lighting up, and helps to manage weight without restricting
food.
-
After you feel secure as a non-smoker, you might begin trying
to lose weight gained in quitting.
-
If dieting triggers cigarette cravings, go back to No. 2. Recognize
that it's more important to quit than to lose weight.
Studies suggest that products offering nicotine replacement help
smokers quit while forestalling some weight gain. Janet Gross, a
professor of behavioral biology at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine,
believs that while either gum or a patch will help you quit, it's
the gum that helps fend off weight gain - at least temporarily.
She speculates it's because gum offers oral gratification and delivers
nicotine through the lining of the mouth.
Also, eating better and exercising before the quit-date make sense.
"Get good habits in place before you break bad ones,"
Dr. Fisher says.
Take your time, adds Dr. Gross. "We don't advise smokers to
change too many things at once - especially if it involves deprivation."
Phyllis Pirie, professor of epidemiology at the University of Minnesota,
agrees. In her study of 416 smokers, people who undertook simultaneous
programs for quitting smoking and losing weight did the worst at
quitting smoking. "We think we may have overloaded them,"
she says. "They just gave up."
|